Wasn't He Tarred and Feathered?
A Delicate Treatise on Togetherness82 total reviews
Comment from nor84
Inspirational. I just may come up with a companion piece, because I think this just has to keep going. I have reported people when the writer said, "oh, I don't want to tattle. Don't want to get anybody in trouble." My silent response to that was, "Then just let people walk on you. They will." My action, however, was to dig through the old offending reviewers comments and write a long report to site administration. The site took action.
reply by the author on 27-Jan-2016
  |
Inspirational. I just may come up with a companion piece, because I think this just has to keep going. I have reported people when the writer said, "oh, I don't want to tattle. Don't want to get anybody in trouble." My silent response to that was, "Then just let people walk on you. They will." My action, however, was to dig through the old offending reviewers comments and write a long report to site administration. The site took action.
Comment Written 27-Jan-2016
reply by the author on 27-Jan-2016
-
Hi, Nor!! You won't believe it. There's about eighteen pieces posted on this. I've never seen anything like it. It would be awesome to hear your voice on this. There's some real morons running around. It's about time everyone got together and took a stand. Great to hear from you. Wow, a six. I'm glad I'm sitting down. HAHAHA!! Thanks a bunch, mikey
Comment from Neil Austin
Thanks for this Micheal, I like to hear true think.
I'm pretty new here, posted a couple of stories and got my jollies, but I have wondered about the wider community and how this site really goes.
Facebook writing groups are the horrors the way folks bicker and peck. My general feel from the lovely reviews I've had so far, is that that's not so much here. Seems mainly sweet and supportive.
Thanks again for your voice.
reply by the author on 27-Jan-2016
 |
Thanks for this Micheal, I like to hear true think.
I'm pretty new here, posted a couple of stories and got my jollies, but I have wondered about the wider community and how this site really goes.
Facebook writing groups are the horrors the way folks bicker and peck. My general feel from the lovely reviews I've had so far, is that that's not so much here. Seems mainly sweet and supportive.
Thanks again for your voice.
Comment Written 27-Jan-2016
reply by the author on 27-Jan-2016
-
Hey, Neil. Welcome. There's some bitter pills running around, but most of the people here are major helpful and cool. Appreciate the kind words on this. Thanks a million. mikey
Comment from Spitfire
I wonder what happened to you. I've been fortunate so far in not attracting vicious reviews. Oh, I've had a few, but I respond with kindness. Well, that ain't no fun. The reviewer wants to duke it out.
I complained to Tom once about someone garnishing high ranking by rewording jokes and wasn't that sort of plagerism? He said it didn't violate any site rules.
Yet, if enough people complained...
Appreciate that you included some comments.
I guess I miss a lot by not going on the forum. But who has time!
Anyway, thanks for sparking the interest.
reply by the author on 27-Jan-2016
|
I wonder what happened to you. I've been fortunate so far in not attracting vicious reviews. Oh, I've had a few, but I respond with kindness. Well, that ain't no fun. The reviewer wants to duke it out.
I complained to Tom once about someone garnishing high ranking by rewording jokes and wasn't that sort of plagerism? He said it didn't violate any site rules.
Yet, if enough people complained...
Appreciate that you included some comments.
I guess I miss a lot by not going on the forum. But who has time!
Anyway, thanks for sparking the interest.
Comment Written 27-Jan-2016
reply by the author on 27-Jan-2016
-
I've been the victim of reworded internet jokes. Yep, I'm still seething. Hahaha! Only a year ago. It takes time. Thanks for stopping by. It looks like this has taken off this time. There's about twenty posts in poetry and prose. It's a riot or a love in. Fun anyway. :)) mikey
-
Yeap. Have to accept it for what it's worth. I don't plan to set the world on fire anymore. :-)
Comment from Pyrrho
A rant is a rant by any name. This reads as though you disdain constructive criticism. If that is so, I clearly disagree with you.
My poetic crafts were already mature when I first participated on the site, but much to my surprise, my ability to write excellent prose was deficient in many ways and three hard-working reviewers taught me more than I ever imagined there was to know about writing skills.
Your writing is excellent, your content is three-star at best.
reply by the author on 26-Jan-2016
|
A rant is a rant by any name. This reads as though you disdain constructive criticism. If that is so, I clearly disagree with you.
My poetic crafts were already mature when I first participated on the site, but much to my surprise, my ability to write excellent prose was deficient in many ways and three hard-working reviewers taught me more than I ever imagined there was to know about writing skills.
Your writing is excellent, your content is three-star at best.
Comment Written 26-Jan-2016
reply by the author on 26-Jan-2016
-
I LOVE constructive criticism and improved ten-fold on three and four star reviews, many from some rather unfriendly folk. I'm not referring to anything like that here. Someone marking a writer down because they don't know the meaning of a simple English word is not constructive criticism, at least in my opinion. In any case, I appreciate your insights and I always take opinions that are offered with good spirit under consideration with thanks. Appreciate the compliment as well. mikey
-
Point well taken. I am not talented at rant reviews.
Comment from johngie
Mikey,
Well said. I am pretty new here and came in on my Aunt's recommendation. I have the same feelings and really appreciate all the posts people have put out there lately. I really hope this changes how some people review--they know who they are.
Keep posting, 99% of use are truly thrilled to read new work.
reply by the author on 27-Jan-2016
|
Mikey,
Well said. I am pretty new here and came in on my Aunt's recommendation. I have the same feelings and really appreciate all the posts people have put out there lately. I really hope this changes how some people review--they know who they are.
Keep posting, 99% of use are truly thrilled to read new work.
Comment Written 26-Jan-2016
reply by the author on 27-Jan-2016
-
Hey, welcome Johgie! You'll find that most of the people here are awesome. There's a few though and you can see we band together when we have too. Anyone gives you grief, this is the gang that's got your back. Thanks for the awesome review. mikey
Comment from barkingdog
Bravo, Michael.
We don't know each other. It sounds like we should have. I agree with everything you have said in this rant.
A friend told me about this group of rebel's ... calling it like it is.
Your roar needed to be heard.
I enjoyed the off-the-cuff style. I swear you were right there in front of me ... not just words on the page.
:) e
:) e
reply by the author on 31-Jan-2016
|
Bravo, Michael.
We don't know each other. It sounds like we should have. I agree with everything you have said in this rant.
A friend told me about this group of rebel's ... calling it like it is.
Your roar needed to be heard.
I enjoyed the off-the-cuff style. I swear you were right there in front of me ... not just words on the page.
:) e
:) e
Comment Written 26-Jan-2016
reply by the author on 31-Jan-2016
-
Thanks for the great encouragement. Yeah, I guess we don't really know each other. I do know of you and even read you from time to time. Good stuff by the way, really good. Cool to see how many of us got into it for a change, yes? Wow. Thanks for the great review. Much appreciated. mikey
Comment from Neonewman
Absolutely Mikey! I have been reviewing all these stand up pieces. I myself fall victim to the obscenity that is ignorance. I will craft a piece and place it soon. I have had friends of mine retaliate against those who offer the low ratings for no reason. I ask what I could do to improve as this is one of the many reasons I am here. Never do they respond back or change the rating(which I honestly don't care)they provided. But one fellow apologized after a friend ripped him a new asshole on my behalf. He said he was new and did not understand the site. He has been directed to the rules and welcomed with open arms.
Thank you for showing those balls of yours and writing this rant to begin with.
God bless my friend.
Steve
reply by the author on 31-Jan-2016
|
Absolutely Mikey! I have been reviewing all these stand up pieces. I myself fall victim to the obscenity that is ignorance. I will craft a piece and place it soon. I have had friends of mine retaliate against those who offer the low ratings for no reason. I ask what I could do to improve as this is one of the many reasons I am here. Never do they respond back or change the rating(which I honestly don't care)they provided. But one fellow apologized after a friend ripped him a new asshole on my behalf. He said he was new and did not understand the site. He has been directed to the rules and welcomed with open arms.
Thank you for showing those balls of yours and writing this rant to begin with.
God bless my friend.
Steve
Comment Written 26-Jan-2016
reply by the author on 31-Jan-2016
-
Hey, my friend. I guess the dust has already settled by now. But it was pretty damn awesome to see everyone out in force raising hell, yes? Got results too. Thanks for the support and great review. Blessings, mikey
-
yes sir it was great to see! And the results are there for sure.
-
yes sir it was great to see! And the results are there for sure.
Comment from mermaids
One of the reasons I am on this site, is because I enjoy reading so many wonderful poems, stories and scripts. I am shocked that someone would give only one star for a poem or essay requesting prayer for one of our members who is ill. Maybe they need to read some stories about compassion.
reply by the author on 31-Jan-2016
|
One of the reasons I am on this site, is because I enjoy reading so many wonderful poems, stories and scripts. I am shocked that someone would give only one star for a poem or essay requesting prayer for one of our members who is ill. Maybe they need to read some stories about compassion.
Comment Written 26-Jan-2016
reply by the author on 31-Jan-2016
-
I doubt they'd understand them in this case. Thanks so much for responding. I'm late in getting back to you, sorry. The good news is, a lot of people jumped on board with posts and it had a positive effect. It's always nice to know you're not alone. Most of us are just like you, we want to post, learn to write better and read some great writing. Anytime someone interferes, we need to speak up. Take care, mikey
Comment from sgalletti
Hello Michael! Well, well, well...I agree with everything you've said here. Lurking in the background myself, I'm enjoying reading this wonderful community effort to put reviewing on FanStory in perspective. I've been on this site for awhile and way back in my portfolio is a similar rant, which preceded my leaving the site for a while. I needed a respite from the grief. Came back of course because I do love posting periodically and reading the excellent writing of several of you on the site. But, I'm here on my terms, not those of the site. I try not to get wrapped up in ratings, contest winning (although $100 bucks is always nice!), tantrums, sucking up for the sake of friends and building a fan base, etc. etc. My observation over the years is that the structure of this site fosters many of the grievances of those who choose to be members of the site. And, people are on the site for many different reasons (including those who have a need to toot their own horns or demonstrate their "power" - or ignorance, in some cases). Anyway, I try not to enter the fray anymore. But, I do support the effort of you and others to address this issue in a positive and creative way (through your writing) and I am very impressed with the "newer" crop of talented writers on the site and the many communal efforts. P.S. Your piece is extremely well written. Flows well, tempers the passion with humor, and makes the point effortlessly and with clarity. Sue
reply by the author on 31-Jan-2016
|
Hello Michael! Well, well, well...I agree with everything you've said here. Lurking in the background myself, I'm enjoying reading this wonderful community effort to put reviewing on FanStory in perspective. I've been on this site for awhile and way back in my portfolio is a similar rant, which preceded my leaving the site for a while. I needed a respite from the grief. Came back of course because I do love posting periodically and reading the excellent writing of several of you on the site. But, I'm here on my terms, not those of the site. I try not to get wrapped up in ratings, contest winning (although $100 bucks is always nice!), tantrums, sucking up for the sake of friends and building a fan base, etc. etc. My observation over the years is that the structure of this site fosters many of the grievances of those who choose to be members of the site. And, people are on the site for many different reasons (including those who have a need to toot their own horns or demonstrate their "power" - or ignorance, in some cases). Anyway, I try not to enter the fray anymore. But, I do support the effort of you and others to address this issue in a positive and creative way (through your writing) and I am very impressed with the "newer" crop of talented writers on the site and the many communal efforts. P.S. Your piece is extremely well written. Flows well, tempers the passion with humor, and makes the point effortlessly and with clarity. Sue
Comment Written 26-Jan-2016
reply by the author on 31-Jan-2016
-
Hi, Sue. Well, the dust has settled already and I'm catching up. (my new years resolution. ha!) Lots of folks jumped in on this one and there were twenty or so postings all over the front page on this and related topics. It helped too, lots of positive results. It's nice to know at the very least, we're not alone. Thanks for your thoughts and insights, you echo my sentiments exactly. AND thanks for the compliments too, those are most appreciated! mikey
Comment from rspoet
Hello Michael,
No need to edit. You've stated the case very well.
I think the best option is to mute and notify the site.
I recently received a "3" on my latest poem
because she didn't understand the acrostic
and couldn't find the acrostic word. It isn't an acrostic!
80 people reviewed with no problem.
When I told her it wasn't an acrostic
she said she might have made a mistake
and changed the rating to a "4" but not the review.
I guess I should consider myself lucky.
I've only been on the site for a year,
but I've noticed a definite change for the worse
Some of the best writers and reviewers
are either leaving or not posting.
I agree that the members must take back the site
from abusive reviewers
Mute, notify and isolate
Your essay is excellent!
Well said.
reply by the author on 31-Jan-2016
|
Hello Michael,
No need to edit. You've stated the case very well.
I think the best option is to mute and notify the site.
I recently received a "3" on my latest poem
because she didn't understand the acrostic
and couldn't find the acrostic word. It isn't an acrostic!
80 people reviewed with no problem.
When I told her it wasn't an acrostic
she said she might have made a mistake
and changed the rating to a "4" but not the review.
I guess I should consider myself lucky.
I've only been on the site for a year,
but I've noticed a definite change for the worse
Some of the best writers and reviewers
are either leaving or not posting.
I agree that the members must take back the site
from abusive reviewers
Mute, notify and isolate
Your essay is excellent!
Well said.
Comment Written 26-Jan-2016
reply by the author on 31-Jan-2016
-
I actually read that exchange and COULD NOT believe it. She never returned, did she? Well, another twenty or so fellow members joined me in this and plastered the front page with posts on this and related matters. It made a difference too. Lots of positive results. People are reporting now and there's very few reports now of this nonsense. Thanks for responding, sorry I'm so late, but that way I get to deliver good news. :)) mikey